1. Supper
Supper restaurant offers comforting Italian dishes in a rustic trattoria with an open kitchen. Reservations aren't taken, but there's a charming wine bar nearby to relax while waiting.
The menu boasts well-executed, reasonably-priced Italian favorites and ever-changing specials. The dimly lit ambiance inside is perfect, especially on a freezing night, with the warm oven in the middle keeping everyone cozy.
Address: 156 E 2nd St, Alphabet City