19 Amazing Pizza Spots In Manhattan NYC

The best pizza in Manhattan New York has to be at Song E Napule. Well, this place has tons of must-eat foods in NYC. This intimate eatery serves brick oven pizzas with homemade Italian pasta such as linguini and gnocchi.

Some of their recommended pizzas on the menu include Margherita Pizza, Neapolitan Pizza, Grilled Calamari, and Carpaccio Di Bresaola.

Neighborhood:

• 132 W Houston St, Greenwich Village
• 146 West Houston St, Greenwich Village
• 464 Amsterdam Ave, Upper West Side

Home to one of the best pizzas in NYC, Made In New York Pizza also has a fun welcoming atmosphere. Their New York-style pizza is mouthwatering and made with fresh, high-quality ingredients.

If you want to try their special dishes, you can order pizza options like Spicy Pepperoni Sicilian, Drunken Grandma, Upside Down Sicilian, and Eggplant Grandma.

Neighborhood: 

• 421 Amsterdam Ave, Upper West Side
• 561 Hudson St, West Village
• 512 7th Ave, Midtown West
• 271 Amsterdam Ave, Upper West Side

SottoCasa Pizza is a standout pizzeria in New York City, renowned for its dedication to crafting exceptional Neapolitan pizzas. The thing that sets this place apart is its meticulous approach to creating an authentic, high-quality pizza experience.

It takes great care in selecting the finest ingredients to ensure each pizza is flavorful and authentic. Some of its popular items on the menu include Salsiccia Pizza, Diavola Pie, Margherita, and Ripieno

Neighborhood: 227 Malcolm X Blvd, Harlem

Great pizza in New York City is not that hard to find. Especially when you have places like Koronet. They have huge slices cut from giant pies and are budget-friendly as well.

Margherita, Cheese Pie, Sicilian, Buffalo Chicken, Grandma Pizza, and Pepperoni are some of the popular items here on the menu to order for the customers seeking a pizza delight.

Neighborhood: 2848 Broadway, Morningside Heights

The best pizza you can find in Midtown Manhattan is at NY Pizza Suprema. The place was opened in 1964 and owned by the same Italian family for over 45 years.

The regular plain cheese pizza is a must-try for its authentic taste and flavor. Its simplicity is its strength, showcasing high-quality ingredients and time-honored techniques. Don’t forget to add a touch of fresh basil on top, which not only enhances the flavor  

Neighborhood: 413 8th Ave, Midtown

Keste Pizza is one of the three authentic Neapolitan pizzerias in New York. This place was established in March 2009 by owner Roberto Caporuscio. Focaccia Di Recco, Calzone Fritto, Via Tribunali, and Margherita are some popular items to order here.

Indulge in an expansive assortment of 40 traditional and creative wood-fired Neapolitan-style pies. The menu also showcases a selection of gluten-free pizzas and vegetarian and vegan options.

Neighborhood: 77 Fulton St, Financial District

One of the oldest restaurants in NYC, John's of Bleecker Street, has been serving coal-fired brick oven pizza since 1929. Their crisp thin crusts are the signature since the very beginning. 

You can order some famous items here in this spot, including Sasso, Margherita, The John's Bianca, Chubby Vesce, and The "Fifty."

Neighborhood: 278 Bleecker St, Greenwich Village

New York's famous food places such as Don Antonio have a relaxed vibe with amazing Italian craft beers and seasonal cocktails. Also, the Neapolitan pizzas here are coveted.

You can indulge in unique options like Pizza Fritte such as Montanara, Pistacchio e Salsiccia, Margarita, Noci & Zucchini, and Macellaio using the fresh ingredients available.

Neighborhood: 309 W 50th St, Hell's Kitchen

One of the top 10 places to eat in New York, B Side Pizzeria is a cool Italian nook. It serves seasonal small plates, creative pizzas, and food with wine and craft beers on tap. 

Order their special pizza options to enjoy with your friends and family like the Marge, Killer Bee, Don Ho, Shrimp Scampi, and Drunken Clam. Also, their ambiance and cozy sittings make your stay elegant.

Neighborhood: 370 W 51st St, Hell's Kitchen

Artistic Pizza NYC is a place where people get all kinds of the best pizza, including vegan and gluten-free pizza options. No-frills pizza joint turning out classic & creative pies & slices with a cozy outdoor setting.

Vegan Pizza, Buffalo Chicken, Slide of Pizza, Vegan Buffalo Chicken, Vegan Margherita Pie, and OG Pepperoni Pie are popular selling items among pizza lovers.

Neighborhood: 

123 W 3rd St, Greenwich Village

Craving for some thin crusts and hand-made fresh pasta? Rubirosa reinvented Italian American classics menu every day of the week. It is a normal serving place of reinvented Italian-American classics and thin-crust pizzas, including the standout Tie Dye pizza.

If you are in Rubirosa, the most recommended dishes to try include Tiramisu, Carbonana, Tie Dye Pizza, Supreme, and Cacio e Pepe.

Neighborhood: 235 Mulberry St, Nolita

Home of the DoughDici and famous spinach dip slice, Sofia Pizza Shoppe is an upscale, neighborhood pizzeria serving New York-style pies & slices with premium ingredients.

A classic, New York-style pizzeria with a modern twist located in the Sutton Place community of Manhattan, NYC Some must-try options pizza options include DoughDici, Spinach dip pie, Grandma slice, Margherita, and Vodka slice.

Neighborhood: 989 1st Ave., Midtown East

Cheap pizza in NYC is served at 99 Cent Fresh Pizza. Recommended items include Cheese or Pepperoni Slice, Ham Pie, Beef Patty with cheese, and Hawaiian Pie.

Quick bites, Italian American Pizza. Fresh and Hot pizzas are delivered to you at low expenses. Also, a variety of delicious meals are provided in a short time.

Neighborhood:

• 1723 Broadway, Midtown West
• 473 Lexington Avenue, Midtown East
• 151 East 43rd St, Midtown East
• 143 West 40 St, Midtown West
• 71 2nd Avenue, Bowery
• 383 Canal St, Soho

A small but classic pizza place in NYC, Bleecker Street Pizza, offers cheap slices and pies late into the night. They serve the Italian taste fresh from the oven. 

Nona Marie Pie, Regular Cheese, Grandma Pizza, and Buffalo Chicken Pizza on the menu are some of the most ordered pizza options in this place. Though it is small, it possess a classy vibe to tune with the pizza.

Neighborhood: 69 7th Ave S, Greenwich Village

Joe's Pizza has been serving classic New York Slice for 47 years or more as of now. This pizza place in Greenwich Village has become just as popular with visitors and tourists

At 75 years of age, Joe Pozzuoli still owns and operates the restaurant providing an authentic New York street slice for tourists and native New Yorkers. You can order Classic Cheese Pie, Sicilian Square Pie, and Fresh Mozzarella Pie.

Neighborhood:

• 7 Carmine Street, Greenwich Village
• 1435 Broadway, Midtown
  

Numero 28 Pizzeria specializes in wood-fired, Neapolitan pizza and classic Italian dishes. The recipes here have been handed down through five generations.

You can indulge in the favorites on the menu, including Rigatoni alla Bolognese, Marinara, Rustica, Eggplant Parmigiana, and Tirimasu.

Neighborhood: 

• 28 Carmine St, Greenwich Village
• 176 2nd Ave, East Village
• 1431 1st Ave, Upper East Side

Food in Chelsea New York at Filaga Pizzeria is traditional and tied to local products. This is an easygoing pizzeria and rosticceria with zeppole, arancini, and Sicilian pies.

You can order your favorites here, including Bufalina, Diavola, Porcini, Parmigiana di Melanzane, and Focaccia Mortadella enjoy in cozy and relaxed sitting.

Neighborhood: 75 9th Ave, Chelsea Market

Missing Italy? Zero Otto Nove is the go-to place. Dining here is like stepping into an Italian grotto in Tuscany. The traditional Italian food and drink here are served in a warm and cozy setting with an old-world aesthetic.

You should try the Margherita for its classic simplicity, the Quattro Formaggi for a rich, cheesy experience, and the Quattro Latte if you’re in the mood for a creamy, indulgent twist.

Neighborhood: 15 W 21st St, Midtown

At King's Pizza of Harlem, the Regular Cheese pizza is a must-try for its timeless, satisfying flavor with a perfectly crispy crust and gooey, melted cheese.

The White Pizza offers a creamy, garlicky alternative, featuring a rich blend of cheeses and a subtle hint of herbs. For something more hearty, the Baked Ziti Pizza combines the comforting elements of baked ziti with the convenience of pizza, topped with ziti pasta, marinara, and a generous layer of cheese.

Neighborhood: 110 W 145th St Frnt 4, Harlem